Don Marquis’s Deprivation Argument
Many people on canada goose factory sale /r/abortion, /r/prolife, and /r/prochoice complain about the lack of a subreddit for debating abortion. canada goose outlet parka This subreddit exists to shut those people up.If canada goose jacket outlet you want canada goose factory outlet to debate canada goose outlet canadian goose jacket sale abortion, come here! You can make arguments as pro choice or pro life as you like or anywhere in between. Topics should be at least tangentially abortion related.The plan is for this subreddit to be lightly moderated. This plan canada goose outlet reviews is subject to change.Debate Guidance Pyramid We expect members participating in debate to be in 1 3 levels of argumentation. 4 5 are less ideal. 6 7 uk canada goose may get you kicked out. This is not a subreddit to let loose at the opponent; it for legitimate debate.Cite. Your. Sources! Do not expect people to canada goose outlet in usa accept your claims buy canada goose jacket canada goose outlet toronto factory without goose outlet canada citations. If you make a claim (especially a statistical one), it your job to substantiate it.DOWNVOTING: canada goose outlet nyc Please do not downvote cheap Canada Goose people just because you disagree with them. Use the downvote sparingly, or everyone is going to be in the karma negatives and canada goose outlet online this subreddit will be very un fun.Become a Redditorand subscribe to one of thousands of communities.4American philosopher Don Marquis, in his canada goose outlet canada goose black friday sale black friday paper «Why Abortion is Immoral», Canada Goose Parka makes the case that it wrong to canada goose outlet uk Canada Goose Jackets sale buy canada goose jacket cheap kill a fetus for the same reason that it wrong to kill an adult: because death canada goose uk shop canada goose outlet shop deprives us of canada canada goose store goose outlet our valuable futures. Marquis entertains and responds to canada goose outlet several counterarguments to the deprivation argument, so this paper is absolutely canada goose uk black friday worth a read for anyone interested in the abortion debate.Here my version of the deprivation argument, though you really should read Marquis paper.Premise 1. In order to figure out if it is wrong to kill a fetus, we must first establish Canada Goose sale why murder is canada goose outlet online uk wrong in the first place.P2. Killing cheap picframer.ca canada goose uk is wrong because it deprives its victim of their future, canada goose coats on sale and all of the value that contains (taking into account the relevant probabilities).P2.1 The deprivation of an entity official canada goose outlet valuable Canada Goose Outlet future is sufficient to make killing that entity morally wrong.P3. Humans like us, in the vast, vast majority of cases, canada goose uk outlet have valuable futures.P4. Fetuses, in the vast, vast majority of cases, have canada goose valuable futures like ours.P4.1 Killing a fetus deprives it of its valuable future.Conclusion: P2.1 + P4.1 = Killing a fetus is morally wrong in the vast, vast canada goose clearance majority of cases.If we weigh the disvalue Canada Goose online of infringing someone bodily autonomy for 9 months against the disvalue of depriving someone of their entire life, it seems like canada uk canada goose outlet goose outlet jackets a whole lot more value is being lost canada goose outlet store in the case of abortion.An unyielding commitment to bodily autonomy can result in some very cruel scenarios that are quite canada goose black friday sale contrary to our moral intuitions. For example, infanticide by neglect would be morally permissible if mothers were not morally obligated to use their Canada Goose Coats On Sale bodies to canada goose outlet new york city secure Canada Goose Online food canada goose coats and care for their child. I think it intuitive that children do have special moral claims on the bodies and labor of their parents.Here another example. Let say a newborn develops an infection after birth, but the mother has the antibody to that infection and she can canada goose outlet store uk transmit it to the canada goose clearance sale baby via her canada goose outlet uk colostrum, thus saving her babies life (grant that we somehow know all of this). However, in order to do this, the baby must suckle or the mother must be milked. Let say the mother is opposed to breastfeeding or having her breasts pumped. In this case, with a post natal baby life on the line, is it acceptable to infringe the mother bodily autonomy in order canada goose outlet canada to save the baby.